Interaction between row space and population in corn

Effects of row spacing and plant population on corn grain yield, moisture, and bushel weight,

SE Exp. Farm, Beresford, SD, 2001.

Main effects and

 Interaction

 

 

Row space

Thinned

population

(plants/acre)

Grain

 

Yield

Harvest moisture

Bushel

weight

 

inches apart

ppa

bu/acre

%

lbs.

Main effects:

 

 

 

 

 

Row Space

20”-row

 

149

16.2

57.8

(RS)

30”-row

 

150

16.0

58.0

 

36”-row

 

143

16.1

57.6

 

*LSD (10% level)

 

**NS

NS

NS

 

 

 

 

 

 

Population

 

20,000

146

16.3

57.6

(P)

 

25,000

151

16.2

57.9

 

 

30,000

145

15.8

57.9

 

*LSD (10% level)

 

**NS

NS

NS

Interaction:

 

 

 

 

 

RS X P

20”-row space

20,000

150

16.6

57.6

 

 

25,000

151

16.3

57.8

 

 

30,000

148

15.7

58.1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

30”-row space

20,000

151

16.1

58.0

 

 

25,000

156

16.1

58.0

 

 

30,000

143

15.6

58.0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

36”-row space

20,000

139

16.1

57.4

 

 

25,000

146

16.0

58.0

 

 

30,000

146

16.1

57.5

 

*LSD (10% level)

 

11.6

0.54

0.64

 

CV

 

6.49

2.76

0.92

*LSD–least significant difference, means must differ by this value to be significantly different.

**NS – indicates differences between means are non-significant.

 

Discussion:  Neither row space or population, alone, significantly impacted the yield, moisture, or bushel

weight of corn.  There was however, a significant interaction for these variables for yield when rows

were 30” apart.  In 30”-rows, the yield for 30,000 was lower than for 25,000 ppa.  Similarly, at

20,000 ppa, grain yield was higher in the narrower rows (20” and 30”) than in the wider row (36”). 

The row space by population interaction was also significant for harvest moisture in 20”rows; where

moisture values were low at 30,000 ppa and high at 20,000 or 25,000 ppa.  The high of 58.1 (20” row

space at 30,000 ppa) and low of 57.4 (36” row space at 20,000 ppa) for bushel weight were the only

averages that differed significantly.

 

Summary:  Neither row space or population, alone, impacted corn production.  In contrast, their

interaction did affect yield, grain moisture, and bushel weight.  The interactions, however, varied

by the row space and population used at planting.  Discussion by Robert G. Hall, Extension

Agronomist-Crops, Plant Science Dept., South Dakota State University.

 

Source:

Berg, R., D. DuBois, R. Stevens, and G. Williamson.  2001.  Corn row spacing and population study. 

SE South Dakota Experiment Farm Progress Report 41:50-55.

View pdf